I'm a big baseball fan, but have little to no interest in any other sports (and no, Professional Wrestling does not count!)
As far as sports games, I have played a lot in the past, but nothing as of late. Earl Weaver Baseball from EA for the Amiga has to be on my top ten games of all time. I also enjoyed EA's 16 bit offerings for football and hockey on the Genny, along with some NES baseball offerings (Bases Loaded anyone :D) World Series 98 on the Saturn just plained ruled as well.
I'm looking to pick up one of the latest Baseball offerings this year to give each a shot, but where should I start? Between All Star, World Series and High Heat is what I'm thinking, but I'm curious which series is most realistic out of the three. Game Informer raves about All Star and I've heard others sing the praises of WSB and High Heat at times. Any recommendations?
