Originally Posted by Sub
and now, a long post because i'm at work and typing makes me look like good worker #1
I don't get the SVC IS BAD vibe all of a sudden. High level stuff aside (sorry dudes, it's been a day since it showed up here, I haven't exactly been looking up infinites), this is exactly the game that we'd had described to us in minute detail for two damned months. Now a bunch of us play it, say golly, this certainly looks like the game that was described to us. Now people turn around, say the game is shit, say the game is broken, etc etc etc. It's been a day since the game went into wide release and about three days since the Cali guys started playing. I don't think that ANYBODY can have an absolute authoritative end-all opinion at this point.
Anyway, moving on to the actual subject matter here:
KOF2k2 is a solid game because it's trying too hard to be 98. That's the feeling the whole game gives me. It feels half-assed, honestly. Also, the special move canceling system was very poorly thought out and pretty much screws over every character who doesn't have a ludicrously strong BC-mode combo. Rag on 99 through 2k1 all you like, and boy can I, but at least they tried. That's what disappoints me about 2k2. Sure, they made it to make the fans happy, but that doesn't mean you just fill out a checklist of wanted characters and make a game out of it.
Most of the SF games shouldn't have been brought to market. It was just Capcom being dumb and expecting entirely too much loyalty of its fanbase. Here are the ones I think shouldn't have come out and helped to kill SF's credibility as a series:
CE: My position on CE depends on whether it was a free bugfix or actually offered as a separate game, because well.... it was just a patch, wasn't it? I've always thought it should have been treated as such.
Super: Obviously rushed to market, everybody knows it, etc etc, I could go on. Super Turbo should have been the only Super SF2.
SF3 original: Second Impact is where the game got good. As it stood, SF3 felt much too incomplete, and there should have been no pressure on Capcom to rush out the first game in a series to begin with.
SFA1: Same as with the SF3 series, Capcom drew some sprites and tossed them into an incomplete game that SHOULD HAVE been extremely important. After Super SF2 made a running joke out of SF sequels, Capcom should not have been trying to milk the franchise.
CVS1: Just wasn't a good enough compromise. There was definitely effort put into the game, but the restrictive character selection process alone (honestly, with a game of this nature why would you RESTRICT who can team up?) nearly kills it. The most embarrassing part is how much better the Neo Pocket SVC was. I'll leave it at that.
VF's always upgraded in substantial ways and has in most cases been THE game to influence the 3d fighting genre. I have no issues with that series.
VF1 invented the 3d fighter, albeit in a simplistic, bare-bones manner. The fact that every 3d fighter has been based closely on this engine speaks for itself.
VF2 seriously fleshed out the characters and the systems with stuff like extra moves and throw escapes. The overhaul was so serious, it's unfair to just call it a tweak.
VF3 experimented with 3D movement and interactive backgrounds. I don't think it did well on either front, but again, the characters were made much, much more complex than they were in the previous game, which alone would warrant a sequel for a lot of series. The only one I could categorize as possibly being a disappointment in some ways, but still absolutely the best 3d fighter of the time.
VF4 took the good elements from VF3 and VF2 and smashed them together. The game is fast like VF2 was (though admittedly not VF2 fast), the characters have freedom of movement, and the rings have variety without creating the strange-looking situations that happened all the time in VF3. Plus they added stances for every character and an entire new attack type in the form of the sabaki.
Seriously now, name me a fighting game series that's come THAT FAR in ten years or any amount of years. These games have utterly failed to disappoint me in any way.
But I am, I'll certainly admit, a total drooling fanboy for VF, so I could be wrong.
edit: note to self: please do not discuss three major franchises in single post ever again