That you for being objective, Tracer. No one, including Rush, has said that McNabb is not a good player, which is the key to this debate making any sense at all.Quote:
Originally Posted by Tracer
I can't remember who called out Brad Johnson, but he is a good example of the double standard here. Johnson is an average QB that led an average offense but a great defense to a Super Bowl win. Your average American has no idea who he is, because, as far as we know, he doesn't eat Chunky Soup. He has, however, won a Super Bowl, something that McNabb has not and likely will not do.
The fact that Saint outright laughed at Kerry Collins being better than McNabb discounts any alleged knowledge he has about the game. Collins is a gun slinger who makes some questionable decision sometimes, but he has a better arm, better accuracy, and better numbers that McNabb. There is a reason rushing yards aren't included in QB Rating. They are not necessary to play the position.
And don't come back with any bullshit about how you watch the game and thus are an expert. Melissa Stark is on the sidelines of a game every week, and the only use she could possibly serve me during a game is to bring me beer.
