Originally Posted by MrWhitefolks
for once in my life i'm not gonna be a complete ass(i dont feel like getting banned for a week) and break it down like this:
if you're anal to the point that you will not pick up what could be a high quality product because of something as minute as "walking animations", then you shouldnt purchase it, let alone makie our heads hurt by posting your opinion(which isn't valid, since you openly admit to NOT playing wrestling titles) about it.
let's not forget that almost NO wrestling game(let alone ANY 3d fighting game) has ever had "good" collision detection. dont believe me? take any of the games you mentioned and punch someone in the head or do a throw. 9/10 times there is some clipping of body parts.
whether it's the fist thru the head, or an arm thru someone's waist, there will NEVER be good or even great collision detection. hell...even when they land from anything(throw, slam, juggle, etc) their back clips thru the floor. it's always dependant on the size of the opponent in relation to the size of the player.
now...considering that the SAME company building Rumble Roses is responsible for the WWE(smackdown/day of reckoning) titles that you say have "terrible game mechanics, animation, collision detection, etc", how the living fuck could you expect a quality title(by your own standards)?
oh yeah, i forgot. you dont play wrestling games.