Shinobi PS2 VS. Ninja Gaiden XBOX

Here is the breakdown in my opinion:

Graphics: Winner - Ninja Gaiden

Music: Winner - Ninja Gaiden

Control: Winner - Shinobi (i find Shinobi much faster and responsive than NG)

Difficulty: Winner - Shinobi (yes i know there hard settings for NG, but im basing my judgement on the default settings, plus the NG bosses are too easy compared to the bone crunching Shinobi bosses)

Reply Value: Winner - Tie (both have great reply value, NG having the edge thanks to the hurrican packs)

i'd say it's a tie for me, i love both....i can't seem to choose one over the other. though i think that Shinobi requires more skill

let's hear it from you girls...and don't forget to vote bitches.

Holy crap, is this a real poll? Ninja Gaiden trounces on Shinobi several times, and takes an epic shit on its face.

Truth. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by U K Narayan

Holy crap, is this a real poll? Ninja Gaiden trounces on Shinobi several times, and takes an epic shit on its face.

Truth. :)

---

I'm the only one that doesn't like NG, so I'll offer the only dissent this thread will see. Here it is...

NG Sucks!!!

In related news, yeah, this thread is silly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by marwan

though i think that Shinobi requires more skill

---

I love PS2 Shinobi, but I really can't agree with this. Once you get used to the controls, the game gets mad easy. It's more about memorizing a level, getting into the zone, and trying to clear an entire stage without taking damage then one hit killing the boss.

This is the most pointless thread ever. Maybe more useless than that portable accessories thread or whatever. I am completely fucked out of my head right now and I can still tell that Ninja Gaiden takes a huge steaming dump all over Shinobi. Like, right in its mouth.

I mean, Shinobi was really cool when it was new. It was a ninja game and it was pretty tough, but Ninja Gaiden kicked its ass in every way possible. Let's not talk about it anymore. It is obsolete.

edit: I vote "shut up marwan" but I cannot find the right bubble.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Grave

edit: I vote "shut up marwan" but I cannot find the right bubble.

---

:lol:

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by EightBit

I'm the only one that doesn't like NG, so I'll offer the only dissent this thread will see. Here it is...

NG Sucks!!!

In related news, yeah, this thread is silly.

---

not as silly as the Revolution controller.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by marwan

not as silly as the Revolution controller.

---

Zing.

The NES version is still my favorite.

Playing it with a group of friends was the first time I learned the phrase "sand ni**er".

I'm still looking foward to playing nightshade as soon as I dig it out of my pile.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by voltz

I'm still looking foward to playing nightshade as soon as I dig it out of my pile.

---

Nightshade is no where near as good as Shinobi.....though not a bad game, it just didnt feel as good....fun to play nonetheless.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by U K Narayan

Holy crap, is this a real poll? Ninja Gaiden trounces on Shinobi several times, and takes an epic shit on its face.

Truth. :)

---

lol!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by marwan

not as silly as the Revolution controller.

---

and lol again.

Why the fuck is this thread being posted in September, 2005? Both are overrated as hell on TNL, but Ninja Gaiden is the better game.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Glitch 2.0

The NES version is still my favorite..

---

IBTN and the Genesis Shinobis are still the best too.

Didn't we have this poll a year ago when Ninja Gaiden first came out?






Oh, Ninja Gaiden by the way.

For these two Ninja Gaiden is better although tate is really neat in Shinobi. I would rather play the 8-bit versions in each case though.

Once you get the controls down, Ninja Gaiden is pure action heaven.

Shinobi is fun, but it can't even come close.

And I far prefer the new Ninja Gaideon to the old games, you people are insane.

Despite it's flaws, Ninja Gaiden XBOX is the better game.

Who are the 2 people who voted for Shinobi?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Korly

Who are the 2 people who voted for Shinobi?

---

Dumbasses. :)

The poll looks like it's flipping off someone, I'm pretty sure it's Shinobi fanboys. Which, if it is, I totally approve. :tu:

And whoever voted for "they both suck" is kidding themselves.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Yoshi

Both are overrated as hell on TNL, but Ninja Gaiden is the better game.

---

Yep.

Next up: Afterburner 360 versus Ace Combat 5.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Korly

Who are the 2 people who voted for Shinobi?

---

I voted for Ninja Gaiden.

P.S. I will love Shinobi III until the end of time.

Shinobi Ps2 was really cool, but it does not come close to Ninja Gaiden.

There is no competition here.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MechDeus

Next up: Afterburner 360 versus Ace Combat 5.

---

If Afterburner was on 360, that would make more sense.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Yoshi

If Afterburner was on 360, that would make more sense.

---

Wasn't it unconfirmed but shown on 360 hardware along with a couple other titles?

whats wrong with Nightshade?
I was thinking of trading in my Shinobi copy & keeping Nightshade, which I assumed it improved all around from Shinobi?
what did it do wrong exactly?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by MVS

Despite it's flaws, Ninja Gaiden XBOX is the better game.

---

My exact thought as well... :chunobi:

... yeah... fuck this thread.

Well I guess I have to say something of content to not be a troll. Ninja Gaiden was made about 4 years after PS2 Shinobi. And you can tell.

But I'm not voting.