Originally Posted by DirtySouth
You *can* make more, but it'll come down to personal choice. 2 of the ingredients, the Slime Crown and the liquid metal armor are renewable and can be aquired again. The Orichalcum (or however you spell it) is another matter. I've found 5 so far in my game. I'm not sure if those are renewable, but I severely doubt it. So, you can make more than one of these, IF you're willing to forgo the other equally valuable items you can make. Personally, I only made one myself. :)