Originally Posted by dhowerter
Well, thats the thing. For me, if a game happens to have Mario in it but its GAMEPLAY is significantly different from say, a Mario PLATFORMER, like for example, Super Mario Strikers, I count it as a new IP.
Why?
If Super Mario Strikers has starred a completely new character (or set of characters) but with the EXACT same gameplay and it originated on GC, even you WOULD count it as a new IP.
So if Mario Strikers has EXACTLY the same gameplay with a new set of characters, it gets dubbed a new IP, but with mario and co it's not? o_O
It's gameplay that matters. For example, it would be ridicoulous to say Paper Mario and Mario 64 are the same IP. One is a turn based RPG, one is a 3D platformer.
In short, different gameplay = different IP :)