I know my Vectrex has analog sticks. I do give credit to Nintendo for actually making the analog stick control fully functional and useful for games. Every early attempt at analog control sucked until N64, IMO.
I also don't remember anyone calling it a gimmick either. We presold almost 400 systems at my EB that year (got in trouble for it too) and I don't recall people calling it a gimmick. All I remember is "holy shit, Mario looks butter, yo!" Ahh, the '90s. :)

