Lost

I thought this was the weakest episode of the season.

Nah, Kate's episode was way weaker.

I love Kate, so no.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Despair

Ghost Psycho Bitch was freaky Nice to see return of Smoke monster and whispers. So she must be dead in real time, since Smoke used her identity to set Juliette on killing quest.

---

Uh... Jack clearly saw her. She even talked to him.

Have two people ever seen the same smoke monster 'hallucination'? As far as I can recall, they've only ever been seen by the person they were intended for.

Even if not Smokey, Harper "thing" wasn't human. It dissapeared once Jack got close to it. We can just guess what it really was.

Rumpy, Kate is hot, but her "trial" story was friggin boring, compared to Others bits and pieces in Juliette's episode.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Bacon McShig

Uh... Jack clearly saw her. She even talked to him.

Have two people ever seen the same smoke monster 'hallucination'? As far as I can recall, they've only ever been seen by the person they were intended for.

---

Yes. Sayid and Shannon both saw Walt right before she got gutshot.

It doesnt have to be dead people too, it's been Walt before and mostly when we were sure he was alive.

I have to agree while important stuff went on during the episode, it wasn't very exciting. After last week's really great episode, it's a hard follow up and this just didn't make it.

Though I did like when Locke brought food to Ben and Ben asked him if the Rabbit had, had a number on the side. Lol! I wonder what happens when you eat crazy science experiments.

I do like Daniel Faraday a lot tough, I think he is turning out to be one of the most interesting characters on the show.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dave is ok

Hurley, Jack and Kate were nowhere near it when it happened, they were on the dock with the Others. Sayid was on the boat on the other side of the island, hence, they're the ones who can leave. Along with Sawyer, Michael, Walt, Sun, Jin, and whoever else.

---

But what about Desmond? Still sounds too specific as the purple light from the hatch detonation definitely reached everyone, including Jin, Sun and Sayid.

I still don't think Harper is dead. Whispers have preluded to living people (Richard Alpert in Ben's flashback, Walt, the Other assault at the end of season 2), dead people (Ben's mom in said flashback, Frank Duckett), hallucinations (Charlie's piano dream in season 2), the smoke monster (right before it killed Eko) and even off the island events (Charlotte Malkin, the psychic's daughter's, autopsy where she came BACK to life). To say that she is dead when the show made no inkling of it either way is kinda silly.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Brand

I do like Daniel Faraday a lot tough, I think he is turning out to be one of the most interesting characters on the show.

---

Yes, way better than Nikki and Lawlo from last season. Frank and Miles are cool too. Charlotte is too cunty though, but she almost needs to be to foil Faraday's character.

Re: Charlotte, makes you think of how Ben tried to kill her. Except she just happened to be wearing a bulletproof vest ... on a premliminary examination of the island. Hmm.

GREAT theory on The Transmission: Ben and Annie were married, and Annie was the first victim of the mysterious pregnancy disease/curse/whatever. Ben took Alex out of grief over his lost child, and wanted Juliette - who looks much like Annie (adult Annie might even be played in a coming flashback by the same actress) to complete the replacement family.