I pick under. They always play like shit against Buffalo in the first game.
Printable View
I pick under. They always play like shit against Buffalo in the first game.
lol @ comparing McNabb to Manning. Type Ryan must mean Eli.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoshi
LOL @ Yoshi's selective reading.
Saying he's "up there with" Manning when he's healthy is comparing them.
To the 49ers fans viewing this thread.
This blows.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoshi
I mentioned Manning's ridiculous stats in my previous post, but since he's considered a top QB in the League I made a legitimate comparsion between him, McNabb (when healthy), and Brady.
Make sense?
No, McNabb has never been a top QB anywhere except in fantasy. And the fantasy stats are solely due to the ridiculous pass happiness of Andy Reid.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoshi
Really? So all those Division Titles, NFC Championship Games (Won '04), a Super Bowl appearance, and 5 Pro Bowls must have meant that he's not a top QB.
They don't mean he's not, but they don't mean he is either. He's a product of the media wanting a black QB to succeed so badly that people who weren't paying attention bought into it. Nevermind that the media should have been focusing on Steve McNair instead. It will be absolutely ridiculous is McNabb gets into Canton, and Brady and Manning are certainly going.
I'm sorry, but to have all those accomplishments on a team that didn't have any offensive stars (besides Westbrook and T.O in '04) is huge and speaks volumes of his ability to lead and produce in one the world's toughest professional sports leagues.Quote:
Originally Posted by Yoshi
If McNabb wins a Super Bowl and puts up the same numbers as Brady during the rest of his career - he could get consideration for the HOF. Don't forget, right now - McNabb and Brady are about even, statistically speaking, but without any Super Bowl rings, McNabb will continue to feel the heat just like Manning did before he won it all last year.