Geoff calls the bitches out and they cut him off. "Wait, he actually knows what he's talking about.... OOOOH, we're out of time"
Printable View
Geoff calls the bitches out and they cut him off. "Wait, he actually knows what he's talking about.... OOOOH, we're out of time"
Yeah, understood, I said almost the same thing in my response to Meach. I respect that.
But I bet you still have to deal with hacks that don't do their job right, or can't write as well as you do with better jobs making more money. Right? So why should that argument be used to impugn the professionalism of game journalists? It's enough of a meritocracy where the people that do it well are successful, but not enough that there isn't any bullshit. There always is.
Hey guys, when is TNL Chicago?
TNL Drrty South imo.
Do it up in the ATL.
I write about video games because I was drafted, and then it became something of a habit. At no point is the word "journalist" going to appear in front of my job description. It's a lot of fun, but hardly of world-shaking importance.
James
The type of journalism I do is to extend the reach of my rage into the hearts and souls of all people. That's honestly all I want out of life. I can act silly and quiet when people see me, but I usually write on the internet because I believe everyone is daft and worthless and they should damn well know it.
I can do that in video game writing as much as I can shouting at people from my car window. Motherfucking spoiled, Long Island drivers. Let's see how far you'd get without daddy's Beamer.
I'm game after mid-October so I can buy mad drinks.
If TNL wants to pay me to write reviews about the various women of the night, I will do it.
I will also travel for this cause.
I'd read it.
Post pics.
Don't get me wrong, I know this shit's not serious business, but "journalist" just means a member of the press. And you have no problem wearing a "press" badge at events. It's a big field, and a lot of people just as goofy as us get thrown in with it. Don't let it get turned into something more pretentious than it is.
You have no dignity...
Heh, my rants in this thread have turned somewhat ironic, because I'm usually very self-deprecating about how goofy my job is (competitive, but goofy), but Meach set off my pretentiousness alarm and I went on the attack.
You're down already? The spectators have asked for their shillings back!
They said they'd burn my house if I didn't take a dive.
God, I couldn't watch that video through completely. The ignorance it holds is astounding.
Reviews are opinion, yeah, but so is being a "political analyst." If you're justifying either on raw opinion alone, you won't get anywhere, though. Ideally it's a qualified, informed, well-balanced opinion that is presented well. Which is why less than 1% of these opinions are deemed worthy of a pay check. There's more to game journalism than writing reviews, too. Most of what I do isn't opinion based.
Don't see what any of that has to do with it being a profession, though.
Well, when I think of a profession, I think of a job/vocation that has specific rules/regulations and/or a governing board or some sort of required education/training.
So, being a lawyer is clearly a profession. Must go to school for it, have to be board certified, if you fuck up you can be disbarred, etc.
Teaching, with all its rules/regs/certs is a profession as well.
I don't think getting paid is enough for a job to be considered a profession (GameStop clerk, anyone?).
What do you need to do to be considered a journalist? Write stuff? Be published? Anyone with a blog is "published" in the strictest sense of the term.
And in terms of whether tossing out opinions is enough for a job to be considered a profession, I don't think that's enough. In my opinion. :)
Meach wins
Well when you write your dictionary, we can discuss this matter further.
Though for what it's worth "legit" journalism doesn't have rules and regs or a governing body, and it doesn't require a specific degree (journo, English, comms, and equivalent experience will all do). So you're not even meeting your own (wrong) definition.
I'd say if you make your living by doing a particular job (especially if it's something many amateurs do for free), you can fairly call yourself a professional in that field. If you fake-wrestle people on TV for a living you're a professional wrestler. Don't make it something magical.Quote:
What do you need to do to be considered a journalist? Write stuff? Be published? Anyone with a blog is "published" in the strictest sense of the term.
Now I DO understand the line you want to draw, but you're trying to express it by making up fake definitions for words. What I do would be what's called "soft" journalism. I understand that distinction between this and hard journalism is meaningful, but it isn't the line between professional and amateur and it isn't the line between journalist and non-journalist.
http://www.superluchas.net/wp-conten...ndy-savage.JPG
If this guy gets the word "professional" in his job description I don't see why I shouldn't.
If the new TNL is just going to focus on reviews, previews and rewritten press releases then you're setting yourselves up for failure again. At least you'll get some free games though.
Way ahead of you.
News is going to be highly opinion based, and hopefully humor-oriented (We've never regurgitated press released at GN, we go out of our way to hammer people who do that). We'll still have reviews and previews (with an emphasis on personal style), but we're also pushing features harder as well as a lot of multimedia content, regular video shows, podcasts, and lots of other stuff. We know what we're doing, don't worry.
That's where all the extra content comes in.
TNL will need something like a Yahtzee to be successful, or something else to bring people in.
StriderKyo should write every review.
Shit, we already have 100 angry video game nerds imo
My goal is to make this a site that you can go to on a daily basis and find something entertaining. Funny, interesting, intellectual, goofy, whatever, but something entertaining.
Not an angry dude, just someone entertaining enough or someTHING entertaining enough to have you checking back regularly. I have only read an escapist article because of Yahtzee, and I was really unimpressed.
The Hipster Review with Mr. K
I'd watch the shit out of that.
My dictionary.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Reference.com
If I said before that journalism is a profession, it looks like I was wrong.Quote:
Originally Posted by Frog
Quote:
Originally Posted by Webster's Dictionary
Are you guys seriously still debating the semantics of 'profession'?
SHUT THE FUCK UP
that gif should be played in reverse now
Who made that gif? I remember working on a bahn gif around that time, but i don't know if i did that one or not?
hazy...
I believe it was K3V.
I'm looking for my bahn avatar. right now... it was pretty awesome.
edit: found it. haha
http://the-nextlevel.com/board/attac...1&d=1201202035
So is this site going to be all IGN-y pro or are we going to be more like actual TNL with swearing and tom foolery?
It'll be a bit of a balance of both and neither. We want the writing to be professional, we're going to have strict editorial standards and all that. But we're going to to want it to reflect the personality of the community as well. So we want to emphasize humor and personality, as well as that nerdy know-it-all side of TNL.
Coming up this week, I talk about 1930s Proto-ambient Appalachian Mountain Bull Singing and its inevitable quasi-ironic comeback. Also This week in fashion: Brightly colored moccasins!
Unsurprisingly though, I would be interested in contributing to this. Writing as a profession (ha) is an idea I've always toyed with but because of how competitive the industry is, how poorly paid (if paid at all) it tends to be, and a general lack of experience on my part--I've never been able to commit to the whole idea. But anyway, I was thinking of picking up a few freelancing gigs and see how the whole things pans out and find out whether or not I'll be eaten alive and left a shallow husk of my former self.
The problem with writing on TNL is that I don't really follow video games anymore.
Join the club.
lol
TNL always seemed about the never-satisfied, everything sucks until proven awesome, and nothing-is-sacred vibe to me. Professional writing is always a good idea, the hard part is not getting stuck between to world's and ending up being nothing important or relevant to anybody.
Some of it is, some of it isn't. Josh and NeoZeedeater are both TNL to the bone, but they don't have much in common. We have a lot of people here. What I intend to do is encourage our writers to have a personality, a sense of humor, and let that show in their writing. I'm not here to tell people to be cynical or what kind of attitude to have, what kind of jokes to make... You can't do that. I just want to get away from the rigid attitudes that other sites have about reviews and features and see what happens.
Some outlets get caught up in what they think a review should and shouldn't be. They think that it's not a review unless they discuss how good the graphics and the sound are and put a number at the end. That's bullshit. A review is just a short opinion piece for an editor to discuss his experience with a game and recommend it or not. Its goal is to communicate what the writer thinks is significant and relevant and to do it in a way that is entertaining. That's what a good writer does. Fuck any other suppositions.
I'd have a 10 point scale from 9.1 - 10. That way no game companies could get mad and everybody would be able to know if a game sucked or not (9.1 being 1, 9.2 being a 2, etc and so on).
Coincidentally, I was listening to the Ramones while reading this.Quote:
Originally Posted by Frogacuda
I don't think Josh likes the Ramones. He's more of a Clash man.
I wanna do stuff!!
Keep a WOW diary and walkthrough. We know you've power leveled every class and race. You can call it a WOW Journal if you want to be more manly about it, but we'll all know it's really a diary.
I really haven't =[ Just two characters ever, pally and priest.
If anyone's been looking at my Facebook you've probably noticed the achievement storm blowing through. I've been getting back into console games in a big way recently =3
no "Kids Corner" editorials by Mzo this time 'round
If my legacy is to be summed in dating a hot 17 year old, so be it.
Absolutely true: Mzo was just on Live playing Sneak King.
HEY NOT EVERYONE HAS MGS4 OK
I was going to go for the rest of the Sneak King Achievements eventually. It was my first 360 game.
He was playing SOTN the other day.
200/200 baby
I bet he was playing wow too. nerd
I have sneak king. Its still in my car from the day i bought it.
Pocketbike Racer > Sneak King
I said it.
That's true.
pls blv.
I still have an extra set of all three games, still sealed and in my closet somewhere.
THAT SHIT WILL PUT YOUR KID(s) THROUGH COLLEGE ONE DAY!
I'd tell you what games I have still sealed and in my closet, but it would lead to flames and jealousy.
I'm going to guess "Virginity"
I have a sealed copy of Rise of the Robots for the 3D0. I'm not sure why.
Also: NES Ice Hockey.
Whats your excuse?
He works in a game store.
The band is back together!
Awesome news guys!
Add me to the list of those who went from TNL staff to a writing career. I've done a lot of paid writing since.
If I knew I had the time to commit I'd love to throw my name in the TNL 4.0 mix. With life today the most I could prob do is a periodic column about balancing gaming with raising a family -- i.e. being a "hardcore" gamer stuck hopelessly behind the tech curve, working on the pile of shame and gaming on the cheap.
I don't think a news journalism career really fits into that example, because I've written for newspapers/magazines for years but I've never considered myself one of those TNL guys who went on to success. I firmly believe TNL only counts those who write for video games.
All I'm trying to say is that my experience as a TNL staff member helped me pursue a writing career. The fact that I wasn't solely focused on games only means that I wanted to pursue broader interests. I already had game industry experience as a programmer so I was looking for other opportunities.
I had no idea you wrote for the site. Carry on.
perhaps not right now, but I've already got some nifty ideas rattling around for v5 (despite the fact that v4 hasn't even launched yet) which include* basically aping Gamespot's union/community blog system :bang:
* includes, but may not see light of day - depends on time, community/administration want, and idea implementation difficulty, among other factors so don't hold your breath for it
Can 4.0 be blue? It's not TNL if it's not classic blue.
I do not like the Hardcore Gamer partnership... :(
I read some of the reviews and like the fact that it's still keeping brief, personal, and insightful. I don't need to know every nuance of a game before I play it - that's why I play games in the first place. But getting an entertaining rundown of what someone else felt while playing? That's a bit more fun than a mechanical breakdown of a game. Reading a review like that feels like homework.