Originally Posted by
Nash
I'm a bit disappointed in the list as a whole, though. This was supposed to be in response to awful top games list put out my gaming sites and publications, but it isn't any better. We criticized other lists for not having any historical perspective on games, but this list doesn't even go back farther than Super Mario Bros. (although this wasn't one of my criteria when I voted). What's also lame is that in the other list that Yoshi put together, the best games of last generation, Resident Evil 4 came in number one by a landslide, yet is nowhere to be seen here. Jet Grind Radio, however, cracks this list but ranked 10th on the last list. The consensus best game of last generation wasn't on anyone's favorite list?