Ryan, are you familiar with this beer or is it the first barleywine you've had? Was it from this recent release? Vintage?
I would agree the style ages very well. I would disagree that it has to be aged. Unbalanced beer doesn't taste as bad as Ryan described.
I've had plenty of hog heaven, old stock, below decks, horn dog, etc at release that tasted fantastic before aging. There's no way southern tier would let an oxidized/infiltrated beer out on the market. I call shenanigans.

