Gamespot at it again...

[Spike]

..scored it 7.3.

Gameplay - 6!!!

http://gamespot.com/gamespot/filters...554980,00.html

Jeff Gerstmann should be fired. This is the same guy who gave Mario Sunshine an 8.0 and Tony Hawk 3 a perfect 10.0.

[Jeremy]

Don't worry, the game scores well in the new EGM.

[hayato42]

Wow thats pathetic

[Adrian]

Controversy for the sake of it. Lame.

[haohmaru]

Haven't played the game, so I really can't comment on the review....

-However-

How can one review this game and call it among the "...most ambitious and atmospheric console games ever made..." , have over a hundred and sixty screenshots, make numerous references to its price and proprietary controller and <b> not have a picture of the damned controller? </b>

>sigh<

[Jeremy]

I guess they feel they did their job by posting previews of it.

Although their exclusion of evidence to support their claims is pretty unprofessional.

[Will]

Maybe they aren't real fans of the Mech genre. I LOVE mechs and if I was able to get this game right now I would.

[PhlegmMaster]

It's not Gamespot that's at it, it's Jeff Gerstmann. I've seen nothing but bad reviews from this guy, although I admit I only started noticing them after I read his Gunvalkyrie review (6.2/10, the fool).

[skelly]

Originally posted by Spike
Jeff Gerstmann should be fired. This is the same guy who gave Mario Sunshine an 8.0 and Tony Hawk 3 a perfect 10.0.

Though I'm no fan of THPS, both of those scores seem reasonable. And dammit, 7.3 is not a bad score. It's clearly marked "Good."

[Andy]

GameSpot's scores are really off the mark lately :/ I mean jesus, the price tag of any game should NOT factor into the score, imo.