Reply With Quote
Utter bullshit. Lawywers are debating the ages of cartoon characters? At what point to the laws stop trying to protect people and just become a witch hunt?
Christopher Handley has been accused of buying manga books of an obsene nature from japan. The trial will start sometime in February.
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news...-case-are-yaoi
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news...-obscene-manga
http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/edit...dley/carl-horn
personally, I think this is BS. A man shouldn't face 20 years in jail for owning gay porn, even if it is something as silly as Yaoi
Last edited by Fe 26; 05 Dec 2009 at 05:52 PM.
Utter bullshit. Lawywers are debating the ages of cartoon characters? At what point to the laws stop trying to protect people and just become a witch hunt?
This is a really ridiculous case, but equally ridiculous is Yaoi, so I'm torn....
This seems to me like on the same level as prosecuting owning a Hostel DVD as some kind of snuff film. Except I don't even think snuff films are illegal.
They are.Originally Posted by Frogacuda
I can do all things through Christ, who strengthens me.
Do you prefer dogs or cats?
I hate this case so much. from what I understand, they're assuming that ALL Japanese cartoon characters look underage when they're just, y'know, cartoons. Unless the artist goes out of his/her/sama's way to make the people look old, every player in the story looks somewhat supple. This case is stupid and so are the people that were supposed to do research on it.
Now, what else is next? As long as we've got a blanket statement, watch out, Ralph Bakshi fans! All owners of Dokuro-chan should run, too! That's snuff AND pedophilia!
.
Even if it was a manga about molesting little boys, I don't see what harm it does to anyone that this guy wants to beat off to it.
Do you prefer dogs or cats?
You'd think it'd keep him from beating off on little boys in public. If you'd ask me, this manga is a great service to the public!
I don't agree with legislating morality. Mainly because none of us can agree on a sensible morality. Some people think its wrong to eat beef. Others think it is wrong to have sex, while married, on your side (or enjoy it).
We can however agree on what hurts people, most of the time. So, imo, the government should only make laws for the protection of people.
This case is BS. Not only should it NOT be illegal to do what they are accusing him of, it isn't even what those books are about. They are about two gay men. He is being accused of having child porn because they have no pubes. They have no pubes because that is illegal in japan. They find it to be obscene (oddly only in porn and cartoons, poor bbobb).
Last edited by Fe 26; 15 Jan 2009 at 10:19 AM.
Well, to look at the flip side, it is pretty common to have the characters in the japanese porns being middle school/high school age, so technically I'm sure some of his porn's did depict minors having sex.
BUT, there's no reason that should be illegal... fucking hell, it's a comic book, who cares.
Last edited by bbobb; 15 Jan 2009 at 07:05 PM.
You sir, are a hideous hermaphroditical character which has neither the force and firmness of a man, nor the gentleness and sensibility of a woman.
Bookmarks