The spirit of liberty is the spirit which is not too sure it is always right. -Learned Hand
"Jesus christ you are still THE WORST." -FirstBlood
It will be good in the worst ways.
Sounds like the typical Del Toro movie to me. He plays a shell game with the visuals to keep you from noticing the crappy dialogue.
"I've watched while the maggots have defiled the earth. They have
built their castles and had their wars. I cannot stand by idly any longer." - Otogi 2
No, that shit sucks. 'Good Bad' is so much more a factor of creators having a big scope or interesting idea that they can't competently or practically achieve. Just making things trite and easily digestible hardly constitutes an homage.
The coolest thing this movie could do, like someone else mentioned, is have the robots created to defend become the new greatest threat. Fleshing out, even in some abstract or fantastic way, the motivations of the monsters would be a great service to a story like this...bad guys are always more interesting because they're the catalysts, the heroes so frequently just react to someone else's plans/ambitions.
That's not at all what I was talking about when I mentioned homages; I was referring to things like the Big O-style arm attack. There were a lot of people on media sites like the earlier YouTube trailers linked where they were complaining about the movie for having monsters rise up from the deep, the GLaDOS voice, and so on.
Gotcha. I was commenting more on the nationalist speeches and Independence Day structure. I don't see why someone would complain about the monsters and robots if the rest of the story was strong, but I can see the subject being an easy out for criticism if the handling is needlessly puerile.
My concern is that monsters, robots, and punches aren't interesting merely by inclusion.
Bookmarks