Originally Posted by
A Robot Bit Me
It's been FORTY YEARS and we still don't have an adequate critical vocabulary for games. I'm willing to bet '40s film reviews didn't say things like, "Take one part Dreyer, one part Mizoguchi, one part German expressionism, and put them all on opium to get this year's MotY favorite, Citizen Kane. But is it worth your hard-earned 35 cents? " We're stuck in the Game Pro mode of dumb comparisons involving drugs I've never used and ridiculous compartmentalizations (ACTING: 7/10: Typical theatrical Welles fare.
CINEMATOGRAPHY: 10/10 I'm happy to say the Deep Focus effect is as BAD ASS at its core advertised. Kane's core graphical experience is unrivaled.
MOVIEWATCH : 7/10: At its core, the newsreel segment was confusing. BAD ASS core moviewatch otherwise.
REWATCH VALUE: 6/10 : Once you discover what Rosebud is at its core, there is little reason to revisit Kane's world.
OVER ALL: 9.24 (not an average) Kane is BAD ASS but, at its core, its ass is perhaps not as bad as How Green Was My Valley's core ass).
It bothers me.
Bookmarks