The TNL Member Vague Game

Uhh... Cowutopia?

Backslidden Paladin

Nick

Clue: Is that supposed to impress me?

Josh/Icepick?

if so, clue: honkey

Militant Honkey, or just honkey?

You're close, Rich.

88mph

It's not Josh, or any username he's had.

Korly n00bs.

Confirmation.

Rezo also got it right but he deleted his post.

clue: Maurice