
Originally Posted by
http://web.morons.org/feature/marriage.jsp
Homosexuals already have the right to marry; they can marry someone of the opposite sex right now!
How strange for those who rant and rave about the "sanctity of marriage" to demand that homosexuals marry someone they couldn't possibly love. Again, it sounds as though the homosexuals take marriage far more seriously than the heterosexuals do, especially the fundamentalist ones. Those using this argument must take the position that "marriage" is a meaningless business contract; but even taking that position, it cannot be denied that the contract is being offered to a certain class of people and not to another based solely upon the sexes of those involved. This is a clearly discriminatory position.
The fact is that heterosexuals presently have the right to marry the person of their choosing (with reasonable limitations of age and genetic relationship). Homosexuals do not, at all, under any circumstances (age and genetics notwithstanding). The two classes of people are treated differently under the law, clearly.
This same intellectually bankrupt argument could be used to argue in favor of interracial marriage bans; after all, so long as white people can marry the other white people of their choice, there's no problem, right?
[...]
Gays want "special rights!"
On its face, the term "special rights" doesn't even make sense. If something is a right, it isn't "special." It belongs to everybody. And according to the Supreme Court in Loving v Virginia, marriage is a fundamental right. Yet, the anti-gay extremists trumpet this "special rights" meme every time gays attempt to attain or retain any type of equal treatment, in an apparent effort to try to convince people that gays are trying to get something that other people don't have.
In fact, it's obvious in the case of marriage that the only group that could be considered to have a "special" right is heterosexuals. They can get married. Gays cannot. What these people should be saying is that they want their own right to remain "special" by preventing gays from attaining equality.
Bookmarks