Uh... yes, Spock Prime is the same Spock from TNG. But by going back in time, he and Nero established a second timeline from which they cannot return. As far as the original timeline is concerned, they didn't go back in time at all, they just ceased to exist. Even if Spock Prime DID try to go back in time AGAIN to stop Nero from blowing up Vulcan, all he'd accomplish is the splitting-off of YET ANOTHER alternate timeline, not a return to the original. This is how Abrams has chosen to answer the paradox dilemma of time travel, never mind that previous iterations of Trek followed different rules more in line with Back To the Future. (Personally I prefer Lost's "whatever happened, happened" approach to time travel [you can't change the past, if you try, you'll not only fail, but probably even find out that your meddling is what caused the events you're trying to avert], but that obviously wouldn't achieve the continuity reset that was the whole purpose of this movie.)



Reply With Quote


Bookmarks