The Hobbit

[Opaque]

Do you not have an imagination? What happens in your head while reading?

You know just as well as I do that there's a big difference between actually hearing a song and imagining it.

There's a reason you have so much music on them hard drives of yours.

[dave is ok]

Melody makes a song - you can't infer melody from reading something.

Songs no one has ever heard written in a book are fucking poems.

[Anthony]

Melody makes a song - you can't infer melody from reading something.

Songs no one has ever heard written in a book are fucking poems.

When I did read them, my mind made up a melody actually, and background instruments. A whole production really, but that's just how my mind works.

[MechDeus]

This will now be three movies. That seems a little ridiculous.

[kedawa]

Maybe they'll be less than two hours each.

[Dolemite]

One book = three movies.

Three books = one movie apiece.

Okay...maybe next they'll start basing films on individual chapters.

[epmode]

They're supposedly working in a bunch of the LOTR appendices.

[bbobb]

Three movies for The Hobbit which isn't even that great in the first place is crazy excessive. Adding the appendices makes it even worse.

[Nash]

It's three movies because you guys are going to see all three.

[Dolemite]

I never saw Fellowship of the Ring, which I think was the first LotR movie? But I saw the second two and found them both pretty 'eh' and forgettable.

I'm ambivalent about seeing The Hobbit once, let alone three times. I give no shits.