New Super Mario Bros. - Wii

[Yoshi]

It takes everything that was good of SMB3 and SMW and combines it into one package.

I will readily admit that this statement is not based on any first hand experience, but I am still calling bullshit on this comment. There is no fucking way a waggle-tainted game by 2009 Nintendo is in the same league as SMB3, let alone taking "everything good of SMB3 and SMW" and combining it.

[Gooch]

I see where you're getting at, Yoshi, because if it does happen to be in the same league as SMB3, then that would mean you're actually misguided and wrong, and we all know that can't possibly be the case.

[SamuraiMoogle]

I see where you're getting at, Yoshi, because if it does happen to be in the same league as SMB3, then that would mean you're actually misguided and wrong, and we all know that can't possibly be the case.

This coming from the guy who thinks Killzone 2 is the best console FPS of all time.

[Gooch]

If disagreeing with the Mog Bros. means I'm wrong, then I don't want to be right.

[Yoshi]

I see where you're getting at, Yoshi, because if it does happen to be in the same league as SMB3, then that would mean you're actually misguided and wrong, and we all know that can't possibly be the case.

Considering only two places have scored this over 90/100 in the US, I have some good footing on the limb I have chosen.

[Gooch]

Ah, internet review scores, how cute. I see now.

[Yoshi]

It's pretty safe to assume they are too high like usual, so if you treat them as the best case they are, then this game is no where near SMB3.

[Mzo]

That last review makes this look and sound like SMB3/Chip and Dale's MMORPG.

And that makes it AWESOME. I think I'm going to buy this and try it out with John; will update later.

[stormy]

i kind of want this game to suck so i don't have to buy a Wii

[Glass Joe]

When was the last time we had a 2D playing (fucking 2.5D) traditional Mario game on a console? SMW? In my eyes that alone makes it worth checking out. I don't even read reviews anymore because these mother fuckers are NEVER right. If it is a game I was interested in and it got shitty reviews I almost always didn't get the game only to play it later and love it. If it is a game that is really, really good on all levels they pull a Linda Lovelace on it and go balls deep neglecting the flaws it actually has.

These fucking GameRanking and MetaCritic sites need to fucking die. They are everything that is wrong with gaming and anyone who looks to them for guidance is a jack ass.