New Super Mario Bros. - Wii

[Tain]

yeah, that shit's stupid, no doubt

[bVork]

Refinement of a good thing is pretty much always better than something new that isn't all that great.

I think our tastes differ there. I'll take a creative but flawed game over a solid well-worn retread any day.

[Low]

GOTY? No.

Surprise of the Year? Definitely. Wasn't expecting the effort put into single player at all.

[NeoZeedeater]

I think our tastes differ there. I'll take a creative but flawed game over a solid well-worn retread any day.

I agree with this. After playing thousands of games over the past three decades, originality and ambition in game design are things I certainly look for. I can still enjoy well-made retreads, though. What I played of NSMB Wii was a lot of fun. I'm definitely going to buy it some time.

[Finch]

It's game of the moment. Game of the year is stupid, like owls that you don't apologize to. It's not like car of the year where there's real measurable criteria.

[Graphics]Um, they're good! Those game people move like they have rigamortis, but it's got lots of pees.

[sound]I like songs!

[New ideas]It's creative and innovative of playing videogames!

[gameplay]You press buttons and shake a stick!

[Overall] I give it the Game of the Year because i like it the best!

[Joust Williams]

[finch] iq of a turnip

[Finch]

[joust williams] nobody likes him but thinks it's everyone else's fault.

[Yoshi]

I'm sorry for saying you and your brother share one pea brain.

How did Gooch get carded for this?

[Nash]

How did Gooch get carded for this?

It was supposedly his third off-topic post in a row.

[Geen]

I think I've said this here before, but I have a higher opinion of this game during my second playthrough as I aim to get all the star coins and secret exits.
In certain respects, I almost feel like I'm playing a Castlevania game as I press against every wall to see if one of them is going to revival a hidden room behind it. Fun stuff.