Your Top Ten of the PS3/Wii/360 Generation (2005-2013)

[Yoshi]

I can.
It didn't appear on nearly as many Game Informer covers as the rest of your list.

Yeah, I think Demon's Souls, Deathsmiles, and The Witcher 2 were on like three each.

You really dug deep for three EA games, two Nintendo games and an Epic game.

[Some Stupid Japanese Name]

Shots fired!

[FirstBlood]

Dark Souls
Portal
XCOM
Rock Band
Hotline Miami
FTL
Journey
Bioshock
Bayonetta
The Last of Us

Deathsmiles at the top of Yoshi's list is hilarious.

[YellerDog]

He likes some dork-chan bullet hell games, that's his thing.

[Timber]

Yeah I can't hate. Pac-Man CE is up there for me.

[MechDeus]

It's not even a great bullet hell game, it's just okay.

Hotline Miami and Journey were both pretty awesome, but I don't know if they'd make it in my top ten. Definitely top twenty. I'd like to squeeze Remember Me in there if only for theme and art design, but the gameplay is just okay.

[FirstBlood]

He likes some dork-chan bullet hell games, that's his thing.

The comedy has nothing to do with the game and everything to do with the clingy hate bubble he lives in.

[Rumpy]

Not numbered because I don't know yet.

GTA5
Forza Horizon
Left 4 Dead 2
Bioshock 1 or 2 2 is really good, but I think the original holds the title
Starcraft II WoL
Skate 2
Mortal Kombat or DoA 5
Blur
Batman AA or AC, not sure. Leaning to AC
Gears of War 1 or 2. I think the first was more holy shit.

On the cusp: The Witcher 2 (I'll probably bump something for this), Halo 4, Mass Effect 2, Portal, Pac Man CE, Geo Wars 2, Alan Wake, Pure, Company of Heroes, Dead Space, Mirror's Edge, Burnout Paradise. Rock Band 2, Rayman Origins, Assassin's Creed Brotherhood, I remember liking one of the Prince of Persia games a lot too, but it's been so long.

[No One]

The comedy has nothing to do with the game and everything to do with the clingy hate bubble he lives in.

It was also kinda funny that he made the bold claim that we'll "show the rest of the internet how it's done" and then listed nine of the most pedestrian, safe picks you could possibly make. Pretty sure he's got his fingers on the internet's pulse, if anything.

10.) Hotline Miami
9.) The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
8.) Bayonetta
7.) S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl
6.) Dark Souls
5.) The Witcher 2
4.) Journey
3.) Portal 2
2.) The Void (Pathologic is better, but missed the cutoff by a few months)
1.) NieR

Edit: As much as I love Demon's Souls, it's insane to me that anyone would pick it over Dark Souls.

[EvilMog]

This is an impossible task. Kudos to all of you for coming up with something.