Can we agree on ONE game?

[Tain]

Antarctic Adventure
Axelay
Cardfighter's Clash
Contra
Cosmic Smash
DoDonPachi
Dracula X
Ikaruga
Ms. Pac-Man
Mega Man 2
Mr DO!
Outrun
Panzer Dragoon Zwei
Raiden
Ristar
Rocket Knight Adventures
Sam and Max Hit the Road
Sega Master System Maze game
SNK vs. Capcom: MotM
Super Bomberman 2
Super Mario World
Super Metroid
Thunder Force 4
Virtua Tennis

Yes.

Hot Shots Golf
Hot Shots Golf 3

No. Sorry, but I still find them to be golf games.

Castlevania 3
Devil Dice (Xi)
Gunbird 2
Kid Icarus
Klonoa
Lufia II
Mappy
Nintendo World Cup
Pinball
Pokemon Puzzle League
Puyo Puyo
Silent Bomber
Strikers 1945 II
Wonderboy
Zillian

Don't know.

I got one. How about... Half-Life?

Sure, it probably won't work, because of that handfull of FPS haters. But I'll try it anyway.

VOOT\'s gotta go.

Shit, you just had to say that, didn\'t you?

Anyway, I\'m going to throw some more up there.

Grim Fandango.

Thief: The Dark Project. No sane person can find serious flaws in this game.

Streets of Rage 2.

Oh, and since it hasn\'t been said yet, I may as well throw VOOM up onto the list. Even if the Saturn port was complete ass.

[bbobb]

I'll throw out Half-Life and Thief... I wasn't a fan of either. Half-Life was good for a FPS... but it was still an FPS.

[Cutty]

Terminated:
Balloon Fight
Gunbird 2
Strikers 1945 II


The New Challengers:
Asteroids
Battle of Olympus
Bushido Blade
Castle of Illusion
Crazy Taxi
Darklands (PC)
Day of the Tentacle
Excitebike
Grand Theft Auto (PC)
Grandia
Grim Fandango
Hang On
Indy 500 (PC)
Joust
Layer Section
Lode Runner
Monkey Island 2
Nights into Dreams
Phantasy Star 2
Power Drift
Raiden DX
Raiden Fighters
Raiden Fighters 2
Sega Rally
SS Bomberman
Super Mario Kart
THPS
THPS2
TMNT (PCB)
Tobal 2
Twin Cobra
Uniracers
Viper Phase 1
X-Com (PC)

[Tain]

Originally posted by bbobb
Half-Life was good for a FPS... but it was still an FPS.

...

What about Thief?

Bushido Blade

Nope. Didn\'t like it.

Crazy Taxi

...Was shot down already.

[elfneedsfood]

What about Frogger?

[Hero]

Originally posted by SearchManX
This is pretty surprising, I saw almost every single Mario game get knocked off no matter how good they were... SMB1, SMB3, SMW, Yoshi's Island, SM64... forget about even mentioning SMB2 (which was probably regarded as the least "Mario" of all the Mario titles). So.. everybody likes Sonic, huh?

That's because Mario games are all overrated kiddy-based sacks of sh!t. Or else, at least that's how everyone needs to front in order to be 'above' the norm. Or maybe they just don't like the game.

Here's what I'd say:

Gunbird 2
Bangaioh
Mars Matrix
Gradius 1 & 3
Life Force
Capcom vs. SNK 2
TMNT: Turtles in Time
TMNT: Turtles Tournament Fighter
Super SF2 Turbo
Pocky and Rocky
Super Metroid
Final Fantasy 3 (6)
Guilty Gear X
Super Mario Sunshine
Beach Spikers
Mario Tennis
Mario Golf
Super Mario Kart
Ridge Racer Revolution
R4
WipeOut Fusion

[EThugg]

Originally posted by SearchManX
Well, the last character battle with Mega Man in it, Ethugg supported voting for MM, so he\'s not all heartless and cold. RIGHT Ethugg?

Welll..... I love MM... never played that specific one though... so I guess I can't hate it... :idea: *thumbs up!*

[sggg]

Based on the list on the first page:

Kill:
Castlevania 3
Mega Man 2
Super Mario World (I already killed this one before )

Sorry, I really truly don't like these games. I know they're all very popular but.. well... I tried to like them. Castlevania is bleh. I like Megaman but I haaate the old NES versions. I have tried so many times so hard to like them, because I think Megaman is cool.. but alas, I don't think so. And, like I said before... I can't stand any Mario games except for SMB.

Nominations:
Adventure (2600)
Power Stone (I don't like fighting games, but I like this game, so maybe it has universal appeal?)
Denki Blocks
Ganbare Neo Poke Kun (!!)
SF Rush 2049 (this seems like a game that would appeal to non-driving game fans)

[Frogacuda]

I would like to kill:

Antarctic Adventure
Cardfighter's Clash
Castlevania 3
Devil Dice (Xi)
Hot Shots Golf
Hot Shots Golf 3
Kid Icarus
Klonoa
Lufia II
Mappy
Mr DO!
Ms. Pac-Man
Nintendo World Cup
Rocket Knight Adventures
Silent Bomber
Super Mario World
Virtua Tennis
Wonderboy
Zillian

Honestly I'd rather have the list of killed games on the main page.

I nominate:
Wonderboy 3: The Dragon's Trap
Monster World IV

[Superstition]

Thanks sggg for nominating Adventure. I love that game, so my vote goes to that one. Unfortunately though, I'd sack SF Rush 2049, the physics in that game drove me batty.